My 11 yo sounds the same. She's outgrown the Justice "look" but still likes their leggings and soft skinny jeans. She also likes the leggings from abercrombie kids and we've gotten great deals by watching for their clearance sales. She will usually wear a longer top if she's wearing leggings - long cardigans over t-shirt, a tunic or oversized sweatshirts, etc. Abercrombie jeans don't fit my DD - she has short legs and muscular thighs. Joe's Jeans fit her really well and we've found them for less than $15 at TJMaxx.