My youngest took a while to find a sport. We started in Dance and thats a good thing to do even if its not going to be your "sport" I kept asking her about specific sports, field hockey, swiming, tennis, soccer, golf, got all nos then i mentioned Baseball and she said she wanted to try it so we did a week camp to see if she liked it and she did so shes been doing Baseball/Softball since. Once she found her sport she ended up giving up dance which wasnt really her thing to begin with. I would ask her about every sport that is offered in your area and see what sports have small commitment opportunities to try them out. Like a week long camp or a month of lessons before you commit to a season or a big expense. That worked out really well for us and you dont end up arguing with them to finish thier commitment to a season of something that they hate lol.
For what its worth I think you made the right decision we are 15 minutes from gym and I joke if it was any further she would have to quit hahaha. Shes fully commited now at Level 7 so I would be willing to commmit to a longer commute but I tell you what at Level 3 I wouldnt be driving more than 30 minutes not with as many days as you end up having to go.