Staying on the apparatuses? Sticking every dismount? Making all his skills, or perhaps the one that is the least consistent that he's competing? For DD, it's been things like sticking her beam routine or doing a bigger split leap. For DS, staying on the mushroom was a big one for a while. Last year, it was a good meet for him if he made his kip and a bad meet if he didn't, regardless of what else did or didn't happen. He was in fact prouder of making his kip at the second-to-last meet of the year than he was of doing his best Pbars routine of the year and placing very well.
Edited to add: I think the coach for our L5s is going to give a special award after the meet to anyone on the team who sticks all of his dismounts, no matter what they score on the events. I like this a lot, because it's something that some of the guys who are still struggling with bonuses might still be able to achieve, and it's something that more than one guy can "win."