I’m not sure that you are as knowledgeable about Gymnastics as you think based on your quotes:
I am not trying to be critical, but 18 months for a mill circle isn’t unrealistic, six hours for a 6 year old on team is pretty standard, and every member on here who has been involved with the sport for years has spoken against home equipment. You’re comments just don’t seem to come from a very knowledgeable base of gymnastics. If you really know what it takes to get to college gym, then you probably wouldn’t even be asking this question. A four hour total commute with longer hours and more practice days and the addition of a TOPs program which you said would want her to do is a surefire recipe for burnout before she even hits middle school, let alone college.
I was brand new to the sport two years ago when my daughter joined a team. It’s ok to admit that you feel In over your head. I still feel that way at times even with two years of my daughter competing. CB is a great resource and I have learned a tremendous amount from the other members here. Let them be a voice of reason for you. There are many parents in this forum with successful optionals, college, and even elite gymnasts. They do know what it takes and they are the ones telling you to slow down and breathe.
A lot of six year olds are passionate about gymnastics and beg for more time in the gym. But what I have learned is that it is better to limit their gym time and keep them wanting more than to up their hours and eventually hit burnout before they turn 10. At their young ages, they don’t know or understand what is best for their physical and mental well being, nor do they really understand the need for rest. That’s where we need to step in as parents and limit them because it’s whats best for them. You wouldn’t feed your kids candy for dinner five days a week simply because that’s what they wanted. We know as parents that it’s not healthy for them. So why do we let 7 year olds train 20-24 hours a week when we know that it’s not healthy for them, but it’s “what they wanted.” Kids don’t know or understand what’s best for them, and sometimes it’s our job as parents to protect them from themselves and to teach them healthy habits.
In my opinion, kids that young that are training that long because “they want to be in the gym that much,” probably have parents that want them there that much because it’s some kind of badge of honor to them or they are living through their kid.