All-Star Cheer Proposed Age Changes For Next Season From Doral.

DON'T LURK... Join The Discussion!

Members see FEWER ads

I'm not really a fan because I think it would be hard to do for small gyms. There is barely any overlap in ages so having cross overs would be difficult. The age ranges are pretty small and I don't think many small gyms have enough kids in each age range to form decent sized teams.
 
What about that one 7yo when all the rest of your athletes are 8+? Or that one 12 yo when you have a lot of 11- and 13+ athletes? Where do you put them?

ETA
Can we not leave things alone for 2 mins to settle before changing them. And if you are going to change them PLEASE do it on a rolling cycle.

The Fierce Board App! || iPhone || Android || Upgrade Your Account!
 
I think this will kill many small gyms if it is instated. It's already hard enough for small gyms to make it so all athletes are on a level appropriate team. Small gyms, and I'm sure even some medium size gyms, need the wiggle room that the current age grid allows. Not all athletes start at the same age and progress at the same speed so a lot of athletes may be stuck on a team that is a level too low or too high for their skill level simply because of their age and due to the fact that their gym can not field another team in that age range at a proper level for them. I think some bottom ages are needed, but I also think that the ones proposed may be more hurtful than helpful. The senior open and junior open allow some flexibility but the youth age, which I consider to be the heart and future of this sport, as well as tiny and mini will be effected immensely.
 
I love this. Senior teams need to be 13-18, because 10 year olds on senior teams is ridiculous
I agree! It is hard for kids that are in high school to relate to kids that are still in elementary school. I also don't feel they should have to do that.

The Fierce Board App! || iPhone || Android || Upgrade Your Account!
 
Tiny should be 4-6, not 0-6. That's ridiculous.

I would add an extra year to the bottom of each mini, youth, and junior be 9-14.

And what's up with the Open being 18 and under, and junior 14 and under?
 
Gosh no. My smaller gym would perish if they tried to put a bottom cap on junior aged divisions. What would we do with our handful of youth 3 athletes? They'd end up being placed on a team lower than their abilities, or we'd have to force a youth 3 team that would hardly be competitive and would push too many kids to get skills they aren't ready for.

I understand and appreciate the bottom age on seniors, but not on the younger age groups.
ETA: The argument for bottom age caps on senior divisions is that younger athletes should not be hearing/participating in coversations and activities that high schoolers have. When it comes to elementary and middle school though, this argument isn't relevant. If it is, then you have bigger problems that need to be dealt with.
 
Gosh no. My smaller gym would perish if they tried to put a bottom cap on junior aged divisions. What would we do with our handful of youth 3 athletes? They'd end up being placed on a team lower than their abilities, or we'd have to force a youth 3 team that would hardly be competitive and would push too many kids to get skills they aren't ready for.

Unless you're close enough to a bigger gym with a Y3, then you just lost that talented, young athlete to the big gym. I feel like the current age grid is fine the way it is, but that's just me. I have a S4 that is perennially a young team, although they do get older every year (ba dum ching...). Anyways, we moved into a senior division a few years ago to accomodate 2 kids that were aging out of juniors. There were 10 year olds on that team. Sure, 10 is young, but not when the oldest kids on your team are 15. I just feel like the current set-up with 10 as the bottom age for non-worlds senior teams and 12 for worlds teams is fine.
 
Not liking the bottom ages either, and where I see the being a huge issue for small gyms, it is problematic at larger gyms too. I'm thinking specifically about the little ones. 3 out of the last 4 seasons we haven't had a Tiny team because there were not enough true Tiny-aged athletes to have a separate team (the one year with a Tiny team, they had 5 kids), and those 3 or 4 kids were just moved to mini 1. Would these kids have to sit out a couple seasons or go elsewhere? Yes. And I'm talking about talented little athletes that have the ability & maturity to handle the older team.


The Fierce Board App! || iPhone || Android || Upgrade Your Account!
 
Unless you're close enough to a bigger gym with a Y3, then you just lost that talented, young athlete to the big gym. I feel like the current age grid is fine the way it is, but that's just me. I have a S4 that is perennially a young team, although they do get older every year (ba dum ching...). Anyways, we moved into a senior division a few years ago to accomodate 2 kids that were aging out of juniors. There were 10 year olds on that team. Sure, 10 is young, but not when the oldest kids on your team are 15. I just feel like the current set-up with 10 as the bottom age for non-worlds senior teams and 12 for worlds teams is fine.
Exactly. This is what bothers me so much. Gyms like ours would lose more than just our senior 5 kids if this rule was put in place.

Another point-- our Y3's (on J3) parents don't want to drive over an hour to get them to a gym with an age appropriate team. Judging by last year, the only gym remotely close to ours that fielded a Y3 was over an hour away and across a state line...and we're in MD! In areas that aren't saturated with gyms, young kids may not be able to find an age-appropriate, level-appropriate team until they turn 11. At some point it makes it difficult for everyone involved.
 
The way I'm reading it, there would be the regular Jr for strictly ages 11-14 and then an open Jr 14 and under so athletes younger than 14 could still be put on a team with like skilled athletes of all ages up to 14....
 
The way I'm reading it, there would be the regular Jr for strictly ages 11-14 and then an open Jr 14 and under so athletes younger than 14 could still be put on a team with like skilled athletes of all ages up to 14....
I think you're correct.

Hmm. That makes even less sense. Why add more divisions that are going to do the same thing that they're trying to stop?
 
I don't pretend to know the answers, but I feel like this is going to really hurt smaller gyms. Not to mention, tell those 12 year olds that just earned Worlds medals that they don't belong on a senior level team.

As far as 10 year olds on senior teams, I can't speak for level 5, but my CP is on a 4.2 and there are several younger kids on there. Judging from the practice last night, they have just as much body control and strength/stability as some of the older girls. If you are looking at it from the perspective of a 10 year old shouldn't be with an 18 year old, I can understand that mentality....but that's where good coaching and supervision come in.
 
I think you're correct.

Hmm. That makes even less sense. Why add more divisions that are going to do the same thing that they're trying to stop?

I don't like the idea of an open junior division for this exact reason. This has the potential to add a lot of additional divisions. What if the ranges were expanded a little that the majority of the ages fit into 2 age groups:

Tiny 4-6
Mini 5-9
Youth 7-11
Junior 10-14
Senior 12-18

Personally though, I am not sure what the bottom ages on the tiny, mini, and youth team really buy you. Is the intent that these divisions need a bottom age for consistancy? I am sure there is a difference in maturaty between a 6 year old and an 11 year old, but if a coach wants to group a 6 year old and an 11 year old on a team together what is the concern?
 
The only thing different is the level 5 and Tiny division. It just means anyone to age 6 can be on tiny. The lower number is not the "anything younger can't cheer", that just defines the division. A 6 yr old could still cheer junior!


The Fierce Board App! || iPhone || Android || Upgrade Your Account!
 

DON'T LURK... Join The Discussion!

Members see FEWER ads

Back