Our booster club does a team clothing order and the most popular item is the fleece jackets with the team logo and (for an additional five bucks) their name on it. My daughter LIVES in the one I got her last Christmas. Team fleece jacket, Uggs, and she's good to go, from October through March!
I got my girls Christmas ornaments that were gymnasts on the balance beam with their name on it. other than that - how about something not gym related?