My daughter is switching from DP level 4 to XCEL gold/plat. I'm curious to see how this plays out since XCEL is used so differently from gym to gym it seems.
It looks like many gyms in our region use XCEL as it's intended - an option for kids who want to compete in gymnastics, while pursing other activities, hence lower hours. Some gyms do seem to use it as a means to bypass compulsories, which means they will train more intensely with higher hours. IMHO, it's very apparent which gyms are training more hours with more intensity in the XCEL system.
My daughter comes from a small gym where DP/XCEL train together under the same coaches, but XCEL trains fewer hours/days per week. My daughter still trains DP hours since she wants the extra time in the gym. Her reasoning change to XCEL was how lopsided her skill set is. She can compete level 7/8 elements on floor and beam, and level 6/7/platinum on vault. XCEL gives her the year to clean up bars without pressure, but still be able to compete skills on floor/beam that she's had for several years but wasn't allowed to in compulsory. If she's still on the struggle bus with bars she can stay XCEL instead of going back to DP.
I wonder if there are other kids who chose to pursue XCEL because of a lopsided skillset like my daughter and where they fit in. Would she be seen as someone who is "working the system" vs someone who needs the flexibility XCEL provides?
OG went to Xcel (the year before it Nationalized) because she was working though a mental block that affected floor, bars, and beam (back tuck, back walkover, and flyaway) and had been working through injuries. She competed Gold for 2 years, took time off, and came back as a L6 in high school. She retired the next year because she couldn't juggle everything (College classes, indoor trach, outdoor track, and a pre-nursing program at the local career center = the only classes she had that were NOT college classes, but might as well have been).
YG went to Xcel because she didn't have her kip after 2 years of (old L4) and 1 year at L3. She did have a jump to high bar directly into long-hang pullover and a flyaway. The funny thing is that she had a full Xcel Gold bar routine (self-choreographed) a year before she was "old enough" to compete Xcel in our gym.
She had no solid acro on beam for Gold, but she had a ROBHS, ROBT, FT, and was actually close to a FT-1/2, and her 1/2 On - repulsion off vault was much better than her handspring vault. Her first year of Gold, she competed without beam acro or a full turn ... and still scored her 2 highest beam scores in all 4 years of competing.
LSS made the switch to Xcel Gold from L4 because she was the oldest on her L4 team and didn't feel like she was getting as much coaching as the younger girls ... and she was going to be the only one to repeat the next season or move up without all of the skills (because she basically gave up since she felt she wasn't getting coached and knew she was going to go to Gold). Plus, her best friend was competing Gold and YG was competing Platinum at that point.
This year, LSS is a senior. She is in competitive dance, track, and gymnastics. She is coming back from several (non-gym related) injuries/conditions that derailed most of last season (ankles, knees, lower back, hip, and DeQuervain's Tenosynovitis that led to numbness that started in the thumb and moved up the arm), so she has dropped back to Xcel Gold at least for the beginning of the season. If she gets her skills back (or if she qualifies for YMCA Nationals in the first 2 meets ... so I can have my "senior" moment at Y Nationals that I missed with the other 2 when they retired early - HER IDEA), she will move back up to Platinum. If she doesn't qualify for Nationals as a Platinum, she will still be able to compete as a Gold.