gracyomalley
Proud Parent
- Aug 5, 2013
- 944
- 1,347
Most three year olds can't gallop, skip, balance on one foot for more than a few seconds, even touch their toes without sometimes falling over, etc. Now with balance bikes its different, but even pedaling a bike is considered a three year old milestone! She is quite exceptional based upon her coordination alone. Honestly, this CB audience is not the general population pool...
Actually the press and the flexibility are probably less impressive at this age than the coordination - strength to weight ratio is different and many kids are strong enough to press, and do all the splits at three if they practice at all (20 hours not required). What they can't do well is balance enough for a press handstand or keep their legs in the right spot for proper splits, etc. DD was picked up at 2 in a mommy and me for her ability to hold "donkey kicks" for ages - and splits, etc - presses were easy for her at 5 and BHS happening at home because we didn't know better...no phenom, but strong and active kid. Held back until 9 for L7, did well, but still done with gym at 12 with puberty. The number of kids in the "maybe talented enough to make it" pipeline is quite large....and the number in L8-10 not so much!
This kid probably gets enough attention at her gym that she doesn't have to "focus" because all the older kids and coaches love "playing with her" at gym (I would assume that's what doing gymnastics feels like to her - one big happy preschool jungle gym - the pictures and videos look that way). No matter how many hours she's doing now it certainly doesn't look like the videos of Asian kids being forced from young ages to hold handstands for 10 minutes or not be fed (or whatever the youtube posters claim is happening...) I don't sense anyone is trying to push her too fast, but I do feel that she's being set up to be hurt, or leave gym long before any of this leads to more than "playing at gym with my friends/coaches..." and I think that the adults promoting this should think long and hard about what it could lead to for her and other youngsters in our acheivement happy parenting environment...after all, you can't play baseball on a team in this country anymore if you don't start Tball and batting clinics by age 5, and gym is already exclusionary enough!!!
Actually the press and the flexibility are probably less impressive at this age than the coordination - strength to weight ratio is different and many kids are strong enough to press, and do all the splits at three if they practice at all (20 hours not required). What they can't do well is balance enough for a press handstand or keep their legs in the right spot for proper splits, etc. DD was picked up at 2 in a mommy and me for her ability to hold "donkey kicks" for ages - and splits, etc - presses were easy for her at 5 and BHS happening at home because we didn't know better...no phenom, but strong and active kid. Held back until 9 for L7, did well, but still done with gym at 12 with puberty. The number of kids in the "maybe talented enough to make it" pipeline is quite large....and the number in L8-10 not so much!
This kid probably gets enough attention at her gym that she doesn't have to "focus" because all the older kids and coaches love "playing with her" at gym (I would assume that's what doing gymnastics feels like to her - one big happy preschool jungle gym - the pictures and videos look that way). No matter how many hours she's doing now it certainly doesn't look like the videos of Asian kids being forced from young ages to hold handstands for 10 minutes or not be fed (or whatever the youtube posters claim is happening...) I don't sense anyone is trying to push her too fast, but I do feel that she's being set up to be hurt, or leave gym long before any of this leads to more than "playing at gym with my friends/coaches..." and I think that the adults promoting this should think long and hard about what it could lead to for her and other youngsters in our acheivement happy parenting environment...after all, you can't play baseball on a team in this country anymore if you don't start Tball and batting clinics by age 5, and gym is already exclusionary enough!!!