I have a somewhat related question on L7 scoring. (Gympanda or anyone)
Under the new rule, there is a notion that some judges would lower the SV (or deduct?) for extra tap swings coming out of a giant/baby-giant before the flyaway (or giant-giant-babygiant-swings-flyaway in our case). Coaches appear to be all over the place on that as well.
The amount is pretty hefty when they do take off for that. This happened in the beginning of 08/09 season. What is the general rule on that? Or, is that still in place?
I'm not sure what new rule you're referring to? Additional swings have always been penalized as execution deductions at .3 per swing. "tap swings" before the dismount are not acceptable. I expect the judges could also apply "swing fwd/bwd under horizontal" (.1 each).
However relatively recently I believe they did change to allow one forward swing before a front flyaway in L7 only, i.e. you could do for example half turn, swing forward immediate swing back into forward flyaway. Again I expect the deduction for swing fwd under horizontal to apply if the front swing wasn't up to the level of the bar.