All-Star Cheer 100's Of Hours Of Practice, Thousands Of Dollars, Plenty Of Blood, Sweat, And Tears...

DON'T LURK... Join The Discussion!

Members see FEWER ads

King

Is all about that bass
Joined
Dec 4, 2009
Messages
14,108
Reaction score
18,903
..and it comes down to 5 minutes in one weekend. I want it to be right.

I say we bring back the universal scoresheet talk, and I recommend the Varsity scoresheet. It makes the most sense. Everything is balanced. It is simple and every category works the same (you cant accidentally award too many or too few points for a category) though you can do percentages like UCA to emphasize building if you really like... but the way the judges score doesn't change per competition. NCA and UCA handed out a score breakdown for each team which got rid of most of the mystery of how scoring works. There would be no misleading in the scoring (saying stunts are worth more but really its in tumbling). Want to reward actual coed stunting? Require it to get into the top rubric.

Thoughts?
 
..and it comes down to 5 minutes in one weekend. I want it to be right.

I say we bring back the universal scoresheet talk, and I recommend the Varsity scoresheet. It makes the most sense. Everything is balanced. It is simple and every category works the same (you cant accidentally award too many or too few points for a category) though you can do percentages like UCA to emphasize building if you really like... but the way the judges score doesn't change per competition. NCA and UCA handed out a score breakdown for each team which got rid of most of the mystery of how scoring works. There would be no misleading in the scoring (saying stunts are worth more but really its in tumbling). Want to reward actual coed stunting? Require it to get into the top rubric.

Thoughts?

With you.
 
..and it comes down to 5 minutes in one weekend. I want it to be right.

I say we bring back the universal scoresheet talk, and I recommend the Varsity scoresheet. It makes the most sense. Everything is balanced. It is simple and every category works the same (you cant accidentally award too many or too few points for a category) though you can do percentages like UCA to emphasize building if you really like... but the way the judges score doesn't change per competition. NCA and UCA handed out a score breakdown for each team which got rid of most of the mystery of how scoring works. There would be no misleading in the scoring (saying stunts are worth more but really its in tumbling). Want to reward actual coed stunting? Require it to get into the top rubric.

Thoughts?

Agree 110%.
 
I'm all for a universal scoresheet, whether Varsity or one made from scratch. But regarding your first statement, I've never seen too many ppl mention this, but I'd say this is also more of a case for reducing teams at Worlds. I'd like those judges to have the freshest eyes possible for each of those teams.
 
I love the title of this along with the first line. So true!

And I also agree ;)
 
Agreed.... but only because I drank the King Koolaid as a part of my initiation to join the fierceboard lol;)

I would like to add that I think the universal scoresheet needs to be weighted for each level, and it needs to have a quantity rubric for stunts. This includes coed, coed "style" in all-girl teams, and 4 person all-girl stunt groups scoring higher than 5 person groups. In other words, a team of 20 putting up 4 stretch tocks using fronts will not be able to outscore a team of 16 putting up 4 stretch tocks without fronts (assuming execution is the same).

I also think that tumbling should be weighted less than stunts. The push to get higher level tumbling skills certainly causes much more long term damage and injuries than pushing for harder stunts. You might get knocked in the face on a double down every now and then, but the repetitive impact of tumbling that is ruining your knees, ankles, wrists, back will be much more long term. That would help with technique, perfection before progression, and would certainly cut down on the injuries.

What do you think if it was weighted like:

Running Tumble + Standing Tumble= X
Tosses + Stunts + Pyramid= 3X

so, say each tumble category is out of 10, then each stunt category is out of 20.
And, yes, we need breakdowns... are we getting beat in pyramids? Who did I outscore in tumbling? etc.
 
I also think that tumbling should be weighted less than stunts. The push to get higher level tumbling skills certainly causes much more long term damage and injuries than pushing for harder stunts. You might get knocked in the face on a double down every now and then, but the repetitive impact of tumbling that is ruining your knees, ankles, wrists, back will be much more long term. That would help with technique, perfection before progression, and would certainly cut down on the injuries.

What do you think if it was weighted like:

Running Tumble + Standing Tumble= X
Tosses + Stunts + Pyramid= 3X

so, say each tumble category is out of 10, then each stunt category is out of 20.
And, yes, we need breakdowns... are we getting beat in pyramids? Who did I outscore in tumbling? etc.
I think you just upset every gym owner who makes their living off of teaching tumbling classes. Don't think tumbling should be minimized at all.
 
I think you just upset every gym owner who makes their living off of teaching tumbling classes. Don't think tumbling should be minimized at all.

Not "minimized"... it's still worth more than every other area on the score sheet except stunts. Why would that harm tumbling business? Name more than 5 gyms nationwide who legitimately have full team, maxed out tumbling? No one. So it's not reducing your tumbling numbers, it's just a way to help with avoiding so many injuries. We're not going to see all of those "doubles" that are landing with legs crossed and 1 3/4 rotation, because they'll be perfecting their fulls instead. It's even helpful in level 1-2. Think about it, how many times do you see janky back walkovers with bent legs and such in Level 1? Or crunched up bhs in Level 2? Coaches wouldn't be as likely to put these gross looking skills in to beef up their majority numbers if the tumbling were worth a bit less
 
Not "minimized"... it's still worth more than every other area on the score sheet except stunts. Why would that harm tumbling business? Name more than 5 gyms nationwide who legitimately have full team, maxed out tumbling? No one. So it's not reducing your tumbling numbers, it's just a way to help with avoiding so many injuries. We're not going to see all of those "doubles" that are landing with legs crossed and 1 3/4 rotation, because they'll be perfecting their fulls instead. It's even helpful in level 1-2. Think about it, how many times do you see janky back walkovers with bent legs and such in Level 1? Or crunched up bhs in Level 2? Coaches wouldn't be as likely to put these gross looking skills in to beef up their majority numbers if the tumbling were worth a bit less
Inyour example of 3x point for stunts the tumbling is minimized. However, what you are talking about is execution not quantity. The top teams will still drive the quantity and, therefore, push others to do the same regardless of the point value.
 
Inyour example of 3x point for stunts the tumbling is minimized. However, what you are talking about is execution not quantity. The top teams will still drive the quantity and, therefore, push others to do the same regardless of the point value.

I can see your point... but, i still think it should be less than stunts.
rt- 10
st- 10
jumps- 10
dance/motions- 10
stunts- 20
pyramid- 15
tosses- 15

^^^^better? :)
 
I can see your point... but, i still think it should be less than stunts.
rt- 10
st- 10
jumps- 10
dance/motions- 10
stunts- 20
pyramid- 15
tosses- 15

^^^^better? :)

It is better. However, I'm all for everything being equal. If we want stunts to be worth more I say do it like UCA as @kingston mentioned above.
 
I agree..but I'm terrible with math so somebody else should do the numbers game.. :)
 
I think everyone wants it to be right, we just have significantly different opinions of what right is.

The issue is not making a decision on one because none are perfect is making a decision.

All skills should be judged the same way with the same ranges. This way judging mechanics don't have to change depending on the skill. To apply percentage values later is fine for a competition to stand out. But really, does any other sport try to set themselves apart by how the actual sport is competed? Each EP can feel free to have as many mascots, stage light shows, sound systems, backdrops, and give aways they want. Be different that way. How we compete and who is the winner doesn't even really.change per scoresheet. Its always the same top teams. At NCA orange, Cali, and panthers battled for the top spots. On a different and more confusing scoresheet it was the same teams.

Last, the safety of the sport can improve vastly if everything is the same. Imstead of.fumbling towards a different scoresheet every comp teams can work on perfection. What I think you'd find is if the NCA scoresheet (yes its NCAs with another decimal place) was made the standard routines would start getting a LOT harder and cleaner.

Sent from my ADR6400L using Tapatalk
 
I think everyone wants it to be right, we just have significantly different opinions of what right is.

I think the problem is that staffs across the country do not know what the scoresheet is really looking for until they see the judging decsions after the prelims at Worlds. If there were a series of competitions that defined to the best of the regional and national judging panels abilities what the World's panel and scoresheet was going to reward, the staffs and teams could commit to the skills and level of execution that they knew were rewarded by the panels leading up to Worlds and ask the Worlds' panels to hold to the judging standards and decisions during the year for that competion. The actual judging on the standardized sheet would define the judging at Worlds as the season progressed and allow teams and staffs to let the routine evolve to what scored the best and gave them the best chance to win.
 

DON'T LURK... Join The Discussion!

Members see FEWER ads

Back