I am a team coach but I am also a pre-team coach and a rec coach. I think every child is important and deserves to be treated respectfully and as an individual, no matter if she is a 12 yo rec gymnast, 6 yo pre-team girl or a super talented 10 yo in optional levels.
Yes, rec classes are supposed to be fun, but they have to be productive too. The kids are there to learn social skills, to learn to love sports and get the benefits gymnastics has when it comes to other sports. I don't know about other places but in here many ice-hockey players, skaters and those who do athletics come to gym once a week because it helps them to become better athletes in other sports. Some soccer/ice-hockey/floorball etc teams actually have weekly gymnastics class!
In my rec classes we practice all the same skills my pre-teamers do, but we don't concentrate on pointed toes and that kind of stuff that much. At the beginning they do some cardio exercise (usually a game), then we do basic stuff like kicks, crab walks, bear walks, rolls, jumps etc on floor. Then they take their own place and depending on week we do either jumps and dance stuff (split jumps, full turns, scales etc) or core strenght exercices fun way. We have contest and I try to use my imagination to make that part nice but effective. After that we do one event. We always set up at least 6 stations (if there is 10 kids) and usually 1 or 2 are for strength. Like box jumps, leg lifts, rope climb etc. We use drills a lot!
Then we do another event.
After that we do a little conditioning. Usually 5-7 stations they rotate.
At the end we play for few minutes together
And with 90 minutes class we also do stretching at the end.
I believe my rec classes are good for kids. They are not serious but proper skill progressions are followed and strenght and flexibility is trained at least a little.
I'm so sad to hear about those poor rec programs some of yo have faced. They should be taken more seriously and coaches should get educated to coach rec as well.