I feel like a lot of people on here are so quick to judge other families for their choices and that's what I don't like. Just because a decision isn't right for me or you doesn't make it wrong for another family. I'm sure decisions about gymnastics when you have a super talented kid aren't taken lightly. I'm sure the parents spend many months agonizing over what the right choice is for their child.
And I have seen the other side of the coin in regards to people judging as well. I have heard quite a few posters comment on how repeating levels is a "waste of time" and if their kid isn't scoring a certain AA score then they should quit the sport because why bother if they aren't that good anyway. Gymnastics is a sport with many levels and varying degrees of involvement. Not everyone puts their kid in gymnastics to become eilte or make the olympic team or even win medals. Some parents enroll their kid in gymnastics for just an opportunity to get some exercise and make new friends. And just because a child isn't super-talented, they still have every right to participate in the sport as anybody else.