Women Judge a routine

[John]

DD was happy to have corrections from the board on her first meet. She used them to improve on 3 of the four events. She was hoping a judge was willing to give her a few tips on her second meet. Anyone have some free time?

 

[Jard.the.gymnast]

I'm not an official judge, but I could try

 

[raenndrops]

Not a judge, but willing.

 

[azara]

Also not a judge/acquainted with ins and outs of JO requirements - but can find general improvements!

 

[John]

Floor
https://www.dropbox.com/s/pvw9istasclmhlq/17 Atlantis Crown Floor.MP4?dl=0

Beam

https://www.dropbox.com/s/e1ca6o6h53kow7o/17 Atlantis Crown Beam.MP4?dl=0

She loves direct input, example knees not high enough in tuck jump. Thanks Everyone.

 

[raenndrops]

What stood out to me was:
Floor:
1. The switch split didn't seem to hit 180º
2. Too much power in the tumbling led to bigger "finishes" that looked a little out of control (small "hop" movements - especially in the full).
3. Her tuck jump full MAY be under-rotated, I couldn't tell for sure.
4. Her 3/2 turn was under-rotated.
Beam:
1. Very bent knees on the BHS-BHS
2. Split jump not to 180º
3. In a leap, the back leg height should match the front leg height... her back leg is very low.
4. Slight pike on the layout dismount.
5. Wobbles throughout... should already know that one, lol.

I hope this helps.

 

[Jard.the.gymnast]

Everything raenndrops says, and
1. Her beam mount isn't in the code. This is a deduction in elite, not sure it is in USAG
2. She waits quite long before she goes for something. This is also a deduction in elite, not sure it is in JO
3. Couldn't really see this, but her facials have to match her music and movements (also elite, not sure about JO)

 

[raenndrops]

Everything raenndrops says, and
1. Her beam mount isn't in the code. This is a deduction in elite, not sure it is in USAG
2. She waits quite long before she goes for something. This is also a deduction in elite, not sure it is in JO
3. Couldn't really see this, but her facials have to match her music and movements (also elite, not sure about JO)

1. Not a deduction in USAG JO.
2. As long as it is not too long (2 seconds or more), it should be fine... I like to limit pauses to 1 second or less.
3. Facials are nice, but not really a specific deduction if they don't match. Might be part of "Artistry" but so is everything else.

 

[profmom]

Not a judge, but I've watched a lot of routines. I saw the same things. Just one addition: I don't know the deduction, but our beam coaches would have been on her for lack of relevé throughout, but particularly on the full turn.

 

[John]

Yes lack of releve. That's funny that's what the beam coach has asker her for Christmas. She wants nothing else.